Does previous playing experience = good coaching?
Advantages of Former Players as Youth Coaches
Game Knowledge & Experience
They understand the technical and tactical aspects of the sport deeply.
Can share real-world insights and examples to inspire kids.
Credibility
Kids and parents often respect someone who has “been there.”
The ability to demonstrate technical skills is high.
Network & Exposure
May have access to higher-level resources and opportunities for players.
Potential Challenges
Coaching ≠ Playing
Great players don’t automatically know how to teach skills or manage youth development.
Many are not trained in how to break down a skill and teach it at a more rudimentary level.
Coaching requires patience, communication, and a focus on how kids learn, not just what to do.
Understanding the process of learning does require more education.
Possible overemphasis on Winning
Former players sometimes bring a competitive mindset that doesn’t align with age-appropriate development.
May focus on advanced tactics instead of fundamentals and fun.
Lack of Pedagogy & Child Psychology
Youth athletes need different communication and motivational strategies.
Some former players might struggle with keeping things growth-oriented.
Some former players may favour athletes that are more advanced and unintentionally spend more time on those kids.
When Former Players Make Excellent Youth Coaches
They embrace formal education & mentorship: Learn child development, coaching science, and effective communication.
All coaches should be evaluated regularly by a peer-mentor.
They prioritize development over winning games and stats.
They adapt their playing experience into simple, enjoyable lessons.
When they meet the young athlete where they are, in their stage of development.
